Quaker Studies Working Group

Rebecca Carter-Chand (Director, Programs on Ethics, Religion, and the Holocaust, United States Holocaust Memorial Museum) discusses “The Historical Turn in Interpreting Rescue during the Holocaust: Understanding Religious Motivations and Religious Networks.”

Accounts of rescue during the Holocaust have long fascinated survivors, historians, and the public. Despite being the exception rather than the norm, stories of rescue have been used to highlight altruism and courage, reaffirm the goodness of humanity, and serve as a counter narrative to the widespread complicity of Christian churches. For several decades after the Holocaust, rescue was understood primarily as a psychological phenomenon that could be attributed to one’s ethical predisposition or empathetic personality, or as a result of one’s piety or theological commitments. In recent years, a new approach has been gaining attention – one that focuses less on motivations and more on circumstances. This talk will trace the evolution of the study of rescue and highlight new research on the rescue of Jews by Christian networks, as well as Jewish strategies of survival.

Rebecca Carter-Chand

Professor Rebecca T. Alpert, (Professor of Religion Emeritus, Temple University) discusses "Judaism Does (Not) Equal Zionism: Exploring American Jews’ Complicated Relationship to Israel/Palestine".

While it is commonly accepted that all American Jews stand with Israel, American Jewish views on Israel (and Israeli views of American Judaism) have reflected the reality that, like all religions, Judaism is not monolith. We will seek a better understanding of the nuances and complexities of American Jewish connections to Israel by examining the history of American Zionism, the role of the Holocaust and Jewish identity, and the effects of October 7 on American awareness of the history and context of the long-standing conflict in Israel/Palestine.

Rebecca T. Alpert

Professor Michael McNally (John M. and Elizabeth Musser Professor of Religious Studies, Carleton College) discusses “Defending the Sacred at Oak Flat: Western Apaches and the Presence of Place.”

Although a pending court ruling could alter the situation, Oak Flat--a sacred precinct in Arizona known to the Western Apache as Chí’chil Biłdagoteel--is on track to collapse into a huge crater that would be created by a proposed underground mine. Drawing on elders’ testimony from the litigation, McNally will explore Apache views of the sacred power pervading Oak Flat, the history of the criminalization of Apache religion at that locale, and the challenges facing Native peoples when they seek to articulate their claims in the legal language of religious freedom.

Michael McNally

Professor Ben Pink Dandelion (Professor of Theology and Religion; Honorary Professor of Quaker Studies; Director, Centre for Postgraduate Quaker Studies, University of Birmingham, UK) & Professor Robynne Rogers Healy (Professor of History; Chair, Department of History; Coordinator, Gender Studies, Trinity Western University, Canada) discuss “The New History of Quakerism”

The way that we understand the history of the Society of Friends today is very different from the way that we understood it one hundred--or even ten--years ago. In this session two distinguished scholars will highlight some of the most important differences between "the new history of Quakerism" and older interpretations of Quaker history.

Robynne Rogers Healy (left) and Ben Pink Dandelion (right)

Professor Judith Weisenfeld (Agate Brown and George L. Collord Professor of Religion, Princeton University) discusses “Spiritual Madness: Race, Psychiatry, and African American Religions.”

As the nineteenth century drew to a close, white American psychiatrists declared that mental illness among African Americans in the South had reached alarming proportions and argued that, in a notable percentage of these cases, “religious excitement” was the key precipitating factor. This talk explores late nineteenth and early twentieth-century psychiatric theories about race, religion, and the “normal mind” and shows how the emerging specialty of psychiatry drew on works from history of religions to make racialized claims about African Americans’ “traits of character, habit, and behavior.” This history of the intersections of psychiatry and African American religions sheds light on how ideas about race, religion, and mental normalcy shaped African American experience in courts and mental hospitals and on the role the racialization of religion played more broadly in the history of medicine, legal history, and the history of disability.

Judith Weisenfeld

Professor Katharine Gerbner (History, University of Minnesota) discusses “Quakers and Slavery in the Seventeenth Century”

Eighteenth-century Quakers were leaders of the abolitionist movement, but many seventeenth-century Quakers were slave owners. In Pennsylvania, William Penn was a slave-holder, and leading English Quakers used their connections to Friends in Barbados to import enslaved men and women. My talk will examine how these seventeenth-century Quakers reconciled slavery with their peace testimony. I will end by asking what it means to truly reckon with the history of Quaker slave-holding today.

Katharine Gerbner

Professor Jennifer Graber (Religious Studies and Native American and Indigenous Studies, University of Texas at Austin) discusses “The Unexpected Outcomes of Peace”

In the 1860s and 1870s, American Quakers invoked their commitment to peace as qualification for their service as intermediaries between Native Americans and the federal government. “The Unexpected Outcomes of Peace” explores how members of the Society of Friends sought to avert war, settle the continent, and bring about Indian inclusion through their work on reservations across the American West. During this period, Quakers developed an understanding of themselves as “the Indian’s friend.” This perception had real effects. While Quaker activity in Indian lands certainly transformed Native lives, the experience also affected the Society. This talk considers how Quakers navigated unforeseen religious encounters and moral dilemmas with an eye toward contemporary conversations about struggles for justice and the role of allies.

Jennifer Graber

Professor Vincent Lloyd (Religious Studies, Villanova University) discusses “The Racist Origins of Christian Education”

The number of private schools in the US approximately doubled in the decade after the Supreme Court ruled against public school segregation, and by one estimate private school enrollment grew five-fold in the South between 1966 and 1972. Many of these new, exclusively white schools identified as Christian, and many used church facilities. Scholars have recently identified this phenomenon as part of the birth pangs of the modern Religious Right: explicitly motivated by anxiety over secularization but implicitly motivated by anxiety over racial integration. This talk will explore the ambivalent Quaker response to this rapidly shifting landscape.

Vincent Lloyd

Professor Kathryn Lofton (Religion, Yale University) discusses “The Business of Being Quaker in America”

“The Business of Being Quaker in America” will observe the history of running businesses "the Quaker way" in the United States in order to decide whether or not there is such a way and -- if there is -- what good it does our economy. From the beginning of the Society of Friends, there was not simple division between religious and economic life; the business life of congregants was fair game for communal scrutiny in meeting houses, and religious practices were embedded in business strategies. Recent discussions about corporate culture have found business management consultants turning anew to religious traditions as potential source material for the cultivation of ethical workplaces. Using the history of Quaker industry, this talk will reflect on the utility of the Quaker way in economic life.

Kathryn Lofton

Tisa Wenger (Religious History, Yale Divinity School) discusses “African Americans, Quakers, and the Racial Limits of Religious Freedom”

The cultural power of religious freedom in the United States has encouraged its invocation by a dizzying array of people to defend every imaginable practice and tradition. Quakers have been among the most persistent and consistent advocates for this ideal, both for themselves and for others. Tisa Wenger will argue, however, that the dominant articulations of religious freedom in American life have more often than not supported white and Christian privilege. Her talk will explore the ironies of religious freedom in the early decades of the twentieth century, juxtaposing Quaker idealism with the limited utility of this freedom for African Americans as they struggled against the legalized segregation of Jim Crow.

Tisa Wenger

John Lardas Modern (Religious Studies, Franklin & Marshall College) discusses “Some Thoughts on George Fox, Religion, and its Cognitive Despisers”

Religion, in a secular age, has become something in need of measured explanation. For how else will religious ever be figured out or its persistence addressed? And in order to measure religion it must be located and pinned down. Whereas the effects of religion may be measured in ritual attendance and the spread of beliefs, the essence of religion is increasingly framed as an interior process, for better or for worse. Indeed, one of the key epistemic and institutional logics of the secular is the commitment to religion as a matter of privately held belief. An enthusiastic focus on what lies behind the eyes and within the skull has been integral to this particular making of religion. Modern’s talk excavates a deep history of one of of the central topics of the contemporary cognitive science of religion (CSR) -- that curious engine of belief that goes by the name of the “hyperactive agency detection device.” Cognitive scientists use this felicitous phrase to discuss the bundle of cognitive processes that prime humans to scan for a believe in supernatural agents.

John Modern